So Catholics Are Just Like Christians, Right?

“So, Catholics are just like Christians, only they add stuff. Is that right?” I stared at my teenager. Was she joking?

Angela understood the concept of Christian unity; but she lost an important specific—Catholics are Christians. Her dad and I taught her this, but even the most diligent teaching gets derailed, if we’re not diligent to reinforce it.

I understand how she got confused. I hear the same anti-Catholic rhetoric that she does. From “it doesn’t take all that to please God,” to Catholicism as “the Pagan whore of Babylon,” and a “Godless theology of hate.” [From, “Should Christians Support Israel?”, John Hagee, 1987]

As far as Catholics adding things, I told my daughter, there are striking similarities between Catholic and Jewish traditions. The Catholic 40 days of Lent, for example, mirrors the Jewish 40 days of Teshuvah. Catholics say that their faith traditions were handed down directly from St. Peter, a Jewish disciple of Jesus. The similarity in traditions makes a good case for that.

Protestants say that Catholics add stuff. Catholics say that Protestants take away stuff. For all of our differences, however, we agree on one fundamental truth: Jesus is the Son of God.

The Bible says, “If anyone acknowledges that Jesus is the Son of God, God lives in them and they in God.” (1 John 4:15, NIV)

No matter how you slice it, that makes Catholics and Protestants brothers and sisters in faith.

“Whoever claims to love God yet hates a brother or sister is a liar. For whoever does not love their brother and sister, whom they have seen, cannot love God, whom they have not seen. And he has given us this command: Anyone who loves God must also love their brother and sister.” (1 John 4:20-21, NIV)

After that incident with my daughter, I turn to the calendar to remind me to reinforce unity through education. We’re using the opportunity of the Lenten season to explore the rich heritage of our Christian faith, and the multitude of directions that God leads his children within that faith. Do you teach your children to embrace believers who follow traditions and practices that differ from your own? Or do you teach your kids to separate from them, because they are not real Christians? Or is it somewhere in between?

4 Comments on “So Catholics Are Just Like Christians, Right?

  1. Awesoem as usual! I taught my kids that it is the “relationship with the Father, through the son, empowered by the holy spirit” not the religion. I did teach them that if a religion takes away the diety of Yeshua then it is a false religion no matter how they wrap it to look otherwise. Just as I believe not everyone in my church is going to make heaven, I believe other denominations have the same, those who will and those who will not. Not because of religion but because of relationship with Him and in the end He judges who that is, not us.

  2. Traditions. That’s the word Jesus strongly spoke against. The Pharisees had their traditions and relied on them heavily, just like some religions today do. Man-made traditions instead of the simplicity of faith with their robes, statues, and the worship of men and women.

    The installation of a mortal man to stand between God and His saints. The placing of Mary as equal and sometimes even greater than Jesus. The neglect of teaching people to read the Bible for themselves, etc.

  3. Dear Kathryn,
    Your questions are very insightful. I would like to explain that I have ben teaching my children to embrace believers who follow traditions and practices other than my own, and that includes the Catholicism practiced by my parish priest. My children thought I hated him, because attending mass always put me in a bad mood, and I struggled to stay positive after a homily. I explained that his form of Catholicism and mine were different and while his practices rubbed the hair on my skin the wrong way, he showed great care and compassion for the faithful. Pastorally he and I agree. Theologically we differ. Just shows you don’t have to go far to teach that lesson.

    God bless,

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Ride the Pen

Your Story. Your voice. the best it can be.

Hebrew for Christians Blog

A personal blog by John Parsons, author of the Hebrew for Christians web site.

The Writer’s Dig – Writer's Digest

Your Story. Your voice. the best it can be.

Grammar Girl Quick and Dirty Tips for Better Writing

Your Story. Your voice. the best it can be.

Writing About Writing (And Occasionally Some Writing)

Your Story. Your voice. the best it can be.

Kristen Lamb

Author, Blogger, Social Media Jedi

%d bloggers like this: